Portugal's Constitutional Court Blocks Local Referendum on Short-Term Rentals: Political Reactions Unfold
Notícias Ao Minuto6 months ago
910

Portugal's Constitutional Court Blocks Local Referendum on Short-Term Rentals: Political Reactions Unfold

Politics
portugal
politics
lisbon
shorttermrentals
constitutionalcourt
Share this content:

Summary:

  • Constitutional Court rejects local referendum on Short-Term Rentals in Lisbon.

  • Court cites lack of verification of signatures as the reason for rejection.

  • Lisbon's mayor calls the decision a "great defeat for the radical left".

  • Socialist leaders express disappointment and suggest the PS should have led the initiative.

  • Liberal Initiative demands the resignation of the AML president following the court's decision.

Constitutional Court Rejects Local Referendum on Short-Term Rentals

The Constitutional Court (TC) has rejected a proposal for a local referendum regarding Short-Term Rentals (AL) in Lisbon, citing a lack of verification of the legality of the popular initiative due to insufficient "effective control of signatures".

This initiative was promoted by the Movement for Housing Referendum (MRH), which aimed to ask two key questions:

  • Do you agree to amend the Municipal Regulation of Short-Term Rentals to require the Lisbon City Council to cancel registered short-term rentals in properties intended for housing within 180 days?
  • Do you agree to amend the Municipal Regulation to prohibit short-term rentals in properties designated for housing?

Court's Explanation

For a popular initiative to be valid, it must be proposed to the deliberative assembly by at least 5,000 or 8% of registered voters in the area, whichever is lower. Three days after the TC's decision on the local referendum, the MRH submitted a second batch of signatures, including 612 additional registered voters, which were sent to the TC without prior verification.

Despite acknowledging that the process presented by the president of the Lisbon Metropolitan Area (AML) was "regularly instructed", the TC emphasized that the collection and verification of the necessary signatures is a "crucial formality" that, if ignored, invalidates the initiative, constituting a significant legal violation under the Local Referendum Legal Regime (RJRL).

The TC also highlighted the need to identify at least 15 representatives for the initiative and for the AML to seek an opinion from the president of the Lisbon City Council, as it is the municipal executive that determines the cancellation of short-term rental registrations according to the law.

Political Reactions

Carlos Moedas Celebrates the Decision

Lisbon's mayor, Carlos Moedas, described the TC's ruling as a "great defeat for the radical left supported by the PS" (Socialist Party). In a statement, he praised the current municipal government's balanced approach to regulating short-term rentals, contrasting it with the previous PS administration, which he blamed for expelling residents from the city over the past 14 years.

AL? Chumbo de referendo é "derrota para esquerda radical apoiada pelo PS"

Socialist Perspective

On the socialist side, Miguel Coelho, president of the Santa Maria Maior parish, expressed disappointment over the invalidation of the referendum, suggesting that the initiative should have been led by the PS.

Liberal Initiative Calls for Resignation

In light of the TC's decision, the Liberal Initiative (IL) has called for the resignation of the president of the AML, arguing that the TC's ruling is a "defeat" for the AML, which they claim succumbed to populism. They hinted at the possibility of presenting a motion of censure if the president does not resign.

Next Steps for the MRH

The MRH indicated that they are "deeply analyzing" the court's decision and will deliberate on their next steps, with further information expected soon. Currently, the PS has proposed a suspension of new short-term rental licenses in Lisbon, due to the ratio of traditional family accommodations to short-term rentals exceeding the legal limit. This suspension will remain until the new regulations are finalized.

Comments

0

Join Our Community

Sign up to share your thoughts, engage with others, and become part of our growing community.

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts and start the conversation!

Newsletter

Subscribe our newsletter to receive our daily digested news

Join our newsletter and get the latest updates delivered straight to your inbox.

OR
PortugalToday.news logo

PortugalToday.news

Get PortugalToday.news on your phone!

Other Latest News

Lisbon in Flames: Carris Bus Fire on Berlin Avenue Halts Traffic - No Injuries Reported

Lisbon in Flames: Carris Bus Fire on Berlin Avenue Halts Traffic - No Injuries Reported

57 minutes ago
920
Shocking Arrest in Lisbon: Duo Caught Stealing from Local Lodging Tenant

Shocking Arrest in Lisbon: Duo Caught Stealing from Local Lodging Tenant

6 hours ago
980
Lisbon's Century-Old Building Reborn as a Stunning 3-Star Hotel: The Palmira Story

Lisbon's Century-Old Building Reborn as a Stunning 3-Star Hotel: The Palmira Story

7 hours ago
1000
Firefighters Control 90% of Wildfire Perimeter in Castelo Branco Amid Heatwave

Firefighters Control 90% of Wildfire Perimeter in Castelo Branco Amid Heatwave

5 hours ago
950
Luiz Carvalho's Captivating Exhibition in Lisbon: Reliving the Fall of Dictatorship Through Photography

Luiz Carvalho's Captivating Exhibition in Lisbon: Reliving the Fall of Dictatorship Through Photography

3 hours ago
810
VIDEO: Benfica's Hilarious Airport Exit Drama in Lisbon - A Must-See Moment

VIDEO: Benfica's Hilarious Airport Exit Drama in Lisbon - A Must-See Moment

4 hours ago
890
Lisbon Ranks as the 2nd Most Desired Luxury Destination for 2025

Lisbon Ranks as the 2nd Most Desired Luxury Destination for 2025

10 hours ago
940
Heatwave Shatters June Temperature Record in Portugal: 46.6°C Recorded

Heatwave Shatters June Temperature Record in Portugal: 46.6°C Recorded

17 hours ago
970
PSP Officer Hit by Police Van Before Sporting-Benfica Futsal Final in Lisbon

PSP Officer Hit by Police Van Before Sporting-Benfica Futsal Final in Lisbon

11 hours ago
840
Alberto João Jardim Praises Jorge Carvalho as the "Optimal and Prestigious" Choice for Funchal Mayor

Alberto João Jardim Praises Jorge Carvalho as the "Optimal and Prestigious" Choice for Funchal Mayor

20 hours ago
830
The Wall of Privilege: How Lagos' Barrier Symbolizes Algarve's Transformation

The Wall of Privilege: How Lagos' Barrier Symbolizes Algarve's Transformation

12 hours ago
940
Jorge Carvalho Steps Up as PSD's Candidate for Funchal Mayor

Jorge Carvalho Steps Up as PSD's Candidate for Funchal Mayor

1 day ago
960
Ultra-Right Party Chega Targets CPLP Immigration Laws, Despite Brazilian Support

Ultra-Right Party Chega Targets CPLP Immigration Laws, Despite Brazilian Support

23 hours ago
950
Southern Europe Sizzles: Record-Breaking Heatwave Hits Portugal, Spain, Italy, and Greece

Southern Europe Sizzles: Record-Breaking Heatwave Hits Portugal, Spain, Italy, and Greece

22 hours ago
880
Chega's Bold Immigration Proposals: Revoking CPLP Special Regime and Nationality Loss for Crimes

Chega's Bold Immigration Proposals: Revoking CPLP Special Regime and Nationality Loss for Crimes

1 day ago
1120
Escape to Nature: Discover the Hidden Gem of Vale do Guadiana Natural Park Near Lisbon

Escape to Nature: Discover the Hidden Gem of Vale do Guadiana Natural Park Near Lisbon

1 day ago
1050
José Luís Nunes Closes Chapter on Funchal Mayoral Race: "Matter Settled"

José Luís Nunes Closes Chapter on Funchal Mayoral Race: "Matter Settled"

1 day ago
890
Heatwave Alert: Seven Portuguese Districts Under Red Warning as Temperatures Soar

Heatwave Alert: Seven Portuguese Districts Under Red Warning as Temperatures Soar

1 day ago
880
Step Back in Time: Lisbon's Medieval Fair Brings Madeira's Discovery Era to Life

Step Back in Time: Lisbon's Medieval Fair Brings Madeira's Discovery Era to Life

1 day ago
960
easyJet Launches Exciting New Route from Lisbon to Tirana - Explore Albania This Summer!

easyJet Launches Exciting New Route from Lisbon to Tirana - Explore Albania This Summer!

1 day ago
1020
Lisbon Rally Demands Housing Rights: 'Homes for Living, Not for Speculation'

Lisbon Rally Demands Housing Rights: 'Homes for Living, Not for Speculation'

9 hours ago
1010
Discover Cachopo Pool: Algarve's Hidden Summer Paradise

Discover Cachopo Pool: Algarve's Hidden Summer Paradise

21 hours ago
900
Alexandra Leitão Unveils Vision for Lisbon: Culture, Housing, and Education at the Forefront

Alexandra Leitão Unveils Vision for Lisbon: Culture, Housing, and Education at the Forefront

1 day ago
880