Overview
The Regulatory Entity for Social Communication (ERC) has archived the case against TVI regarding comments made about Miss Portugal 2023, Marina Machete. The regulator received 40 complaints between October 26 and November 15, 2023, following remarks made by commentator Miguel Sousa Tavares and journalist José Alberto Carvalho.
Comments Under Scrutiny
In the October 26 edition of Jornal Nacional, Tavares stated that he did not believe it was legitimate for a transgender person to compete in female beauty contests, suggesting it was unfair. Despite the complaints, the ERC concluded that the comments fell under the exercise of freedom of expression and did not constitute hate speech. They noted that the target of the comments, Machete, did not file a complaint herself.
Reactions and Responses
Machete expressed her disappointment during an interview, stating she expected more support and acknowledgment of the work needed to address such controversial topics. She emphasized the importance of continuing conversations about transgender existence and rights.
Apology Issued
Following the backlash, Carvalho issued a public apology to Machete and her supporters during a subsequent broadcast.
Conclusion
The ERC's decision reflects a balance between freedom of expression and the ongoing discussions surrounding gender identity and representation in media.
Comments
Join Our Community
Sign up to share your thoughts, engage with others, and become part of our growing community.
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts and start the conversation!