Miss Portugal 2023 Controversy: Regulator Decides Against Action Over Transgender Comments
The Portugal News6 months ago
940

Miss Portugal 2023 Controversy: Regulator Decides Against Action Over Transgender Comments

Society
missportugal
transrights
erc
tvi
freedomofexpression
Share this content:

Summary:

  • ERC archives case against TVI regarding Miss Portugal 2023 comments

  • Received 40 complaints about comments perceived as offensive

  • Comments by Miguel Sousa Tavares deemed within the scope of freedom of expression

  • Marina Machete expresses disappointment but highlights the need for dialogue

  • José Alberto Carvalho issues public apology following backlash

Overview

The Regulatory Entity for Social Communication (ERC) has archived the case against TVI regarding comments made about Miss Portugal 2023, Marina Machete. The regulator received 40 complaints between October 26 and November 15, 2023, following remarks made by commentator Miguel Sousa Tavares and journalist José Alberto Carvalho.

Comments Under Scrutiny

In the October 26 edition of Jornal Nacional, Tavares stated that he did not believe it was legitimate for a transgender person to compete in female beauty contests, suggesting it was unfair. Despite the complaints, the ERC concluded that the comments fell under the exercise of freedom of expression and did not constitute hate speech. They noted that the target of the comments, Machete, did not file a complaint herself.

Reactions and Responses

Machete expressed her disappointment during an interview, stating she expected more support and acknowledgment of the work needed to address such controversial topics. She emphasized the importance of continuing conversations about transgender existence and rights.

Apology Issued

Following the backlash, Carvalho issued a public apology to Machete and her supporters during a subsequent broadcast.

Conclusion

The ERC's decision reflects a balance between freedom of expression and the ongoing discussions surrounding gender identity and representation in media.

Comments

0

Join Our Community

Sign up to share your thoughts, engage with others, and become part of our growing community.

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts and start the conversation!

Newsletter

Subscribe our newsletter to receive our daily digested news

Join our newsletter and get the latest updates delivered straight to your inbox.

OR
PortugalToday.news logo

PortugalToday.news

Get PortugalToday.news on your phone!

Other Latest News

From Chinese Buffets to Exclusive Omakase: How Lisbon Embraces Asian Culinary Trends

From Chinese Buffets to Exclusive Omakase: How Lisbon Embraces Asian Culinary Trends

3 hours ago
850
Cascais Line Disrupted: Alternating Train Services Between Alcântara and Cais do Sodré Due to Overhead Wire Failure

Cascais Line Disrupted: Alternating Train Services Between Alcântara and Cais do Sodré Due to Overhead Wire Failure

4 hours ago
900
Higher Education Reform in Portugal: 11 Key Questions Answered

Higher Education Reform in Portugal: 11 Key Questions Answered

48 minutes ago
960
Shocking Allegations: PSP Officers Accused of Brutal Attacks and Sexual Abuse in Lisbon

Shocking Allegations: PSP Officers Accused of Brutal Attacks and Sexual Abuse in Lisbon

8 hours ago
940
Lisbon's Battle Against Heatwaves: Urban Experts Propose Eco-Friendly Solutions

Lisbon's Battle Against Heatwaves: Urban Experts Propose Eco-Friendly Solutions

12 hours ago
940
Lisbon's New Cyclo-Pedestrian Bridge Connects Central Axis to Eastern Areas

Lisbon's New Cyclo-Pedestrian Bridge Connects Central Axis to Eastern Areas

15 hours ago
850
Portugal Approves New Border Police Unit Amidst Political Standoff and Immigration Restrictions

Portugal Approves New Border Police Unit Amidst Political Standoff and Immigration Restrictions

17 hours ago
960
PSD and PCP Proposals on Mobility Subsidy Approved in Portuguese Parliament

PSD and PCP Proposals on Mobility Subsidy Approved in Portuguese Parliament

20 hours ago
1030
Lisbon Crackdown: PSP Shuts Down Illegal Lodgings and Identifies 26 in Major Raid

Lisbon Crackdown: PSP Shuts Down Illegal Lodgings and Identifies 26 in Major Raid

21 hours ago
950
Shocking Armed Robbery in Lisbon: Son of Angolan Judge Targeted in Benfica Apartment

Shocking Armed Robbery in Lisbon: Son of Angolan Judge Targeted in Benfica Apartment

23 hours ago
1060
iServices Expands in Lisbon with New Store on Rua do Ouro

iServices Expands in Lisbon with New Store on Rua do Ouro

16 hours ago
880
Dreamy Getaway for Less: Portuguese Influencer Reveals Stunning Alternative to Algarve

Dreamy Getaway for Less: Portuguese Influencer Reveals Stunning Alternative to Algarve

7 hours ago
920
Parliament Launches Inquiry into INEM's Management and Recent Strike

Parliament Launches Inquiry into INEM's Management and Recent Strike

18 hours ago
880
Alkantara Festival Kicks Off November 14th with Award-Winning Choreographer

Alkantara Festival Kicks Off November 14th with Award-Winning Choreographer

14 hours ago
910
Court Rejects Sócrates' Request to Remove Judge and Fines Him €1020 in Marquês Case

Court Rejects Sócrates' Request to Remove Judge and Fines Him €1020 in Marquês Case

1 day ago
980
Middlesbrough FC Wraps Up Productive Training Week in Portugal Ahead of Santa Clara Clash

Middlesbrough FC Wraps Up Productive Training Week in Portugal Ahead of Santa Clara Clash

13 hours ago
940
Lisbon's Art Nouveau Gem: Camillo 25 Blends History with Modern Luxury

Lisbon's Art Nouveau Gem: Camillo 25 Blends History with Modern Luxury

1 day ago
990
Tragic Premature Birth in Ambulance: Hospital Director Speaks Out

Tragic Premature Birth in Ambulance: Hospital Director Speaks Out

1 day ago
860
Chega Party's Lisbon Headquarters Vandalized in Shocking Night Attack

Chega Party's Lisbon Headquarters Vandalized in Shocking Night Attack

1 day ago
1070
Carlos Moedas Announces Re-election Bid for Lisbon Mayor: What's Next for the Capital?

Carlos Moedas Announces Re-election Bid for Lisbon Mayor: What's Next for the Capital?

1 day ago
880
Portugal's Strategic Move: Valuing State's 50.1% Stake in TAP with a Credible Partner

Portugal's Strategic Move: Valuing State's 50.1% Stake in TAP with a Credible Partner

1 day ago
840
Shocking Video Leads to Arrest of Two Lisbon Police Officers for Alleged Torture

Shocking Video Leads to Arrest of Two Lisbon Police Officers for Alleged Torture

2 days ago
920
Sócrates Fights Tooth and Nail, Calls MP's Actions 'Cowardly' Over Parque Escolar

Sócrates Fights Tooth and Nail, Calls MP's Actions 'Cowardly' Over Parque Escolar

1 day ago
920
Miracle on the Fast Lane: Baby Born on Barreiro Highway with Family's Help

Miracle on the Fast Lane: Baby Born on Barreiro Highway with Family's Help

1 day ago
810
Benson Boone Explores Cascais and Lisbon Before Stunning Performance at Alive Festival

Benson Boone Explores Cascais and Lisbon Before Stunning Performance at Alive Festival

1 day ago
870